Chris McKee is back with a topical question: at the price of around $699, should you invest in a new iPhone 12 Mini or look for a new guitar? Coming from our resident guitar AND tech addict, there’s a compelling case against the inherent obsolescence of technology that needs to be discussed… but does that also extend to the world of guitars? Let us know your thoughts, considering the lasting value and impact on your life that a new instrument or a new phone could impart– which would you…
I just put the second screen on my G6 I bought years ago and it still rocks. If I could just stop leaving it in my lap when I get out the car… I've also had the same crappy looking Fender stickercaster I bought in a pawn shop in the 90's and it sounds better than ever, or maybe it's the amp.
Where are the Lesson videos Chris??
The iPhone 12 is superb. My wife got it and for the first time ever I have iPhone envy. To get a guitar that’s a match for the 12 you need to spend a lot more.
My 1st guitar, 1967 Airline, (HH6600) catalog price of $79. Still have it. 1994 a $400 Washburn with a value today of $400 w case. Dad's 1st & only 2007 Motorola flip cellphone won't work on Verizon network anymore. Sad cause he's not with learning new. He still played guitar since the 1920s. Yes get the guitar.
Desperately trying to follow your speech, but I can’t help staring at your Apple watch. Hmmm, maybe I should buy one 😉
That is why I‘m not a big fan of modeling amps. They take something that should last for years and tie it to technology that will be obsolete shortly.
I get it. A phone will help you communicate with family and loved ones, help you get where you need to be with its gps, find a new job over the internet, etc.. A guitar won’t “expire” per say though.
I am a huge apple nerd- Ive owned every iPhone since the very first release. Did I buy the new iPhone 12 Pro- yes. Did I also just buy a mocha burst Jazzmaster Ultra – also yes!! Which will I get more fulfillment from – the guitar of course!
Ironically, Fender seems to be following the Apple model, now they have an American Profession II. I’m afraid in ten years they will have the American Profession 12 with updates and price increases every year.
Buy a cheap android that will do everything the iphone does… for about $250
If you pay more than that, you're what is commonly referred to as a … sucker
Buy the guitar. Obviously. Chris, off topic: can you review Furch Yellow MC (Cedar/Rosewood) to most recent (2019?) Taylor 314ce Limited (also Cedar/Rosewood) – I love Taylor brand, but they don't normally have this tonewood combo, certainly not at a 300 series price. Both guitars are very hard to find so I can't play either of them to see/hear for myself.
Just ordered a new $18 battery for my 3-y-o $80 Doogee android phone. This year I've spent less than $170 on gear (ext cabinet and tube preamp from me, bass combo amp for my son). My last two new used guitars came as exchange and trade-in, and will not scratch my itch for a Gibson SG for some time. I love your message, man; still, happier when resisting GAS of any kind.
3:55 did he say epiphone haha!
Even if and when you decide to stop using both an IPhone won’t look cool hanging on your wall! 😉🤙
No argument. Tech is obsolete after 6 months, never mind a year! Guitars though, will last a lifetime ,and ,give as much as you put in! No contest.
A phone may do a whole shit load of things. But 90% of them you can live without if you memorise routes before you leave, and turn up when you say you will.
I needed to upgrade my S7Edge phone but I ended up picking up an electron green player tele. I rationalized it by saying since Fender only made 200 of them it would be a collector's item. Yes…a…collector's item indeed…
This is such a GREAT video, it got me laughing so hard!! But in all honesty, I’ll take a Tele or another Strat over a new phone!!
Guitar! Guitar! I'm still happily using a Samsung S5 Galaxy, and I just picked up a MIM Strat! Guitar! Guitar!
another great video!
Not even close. iPhone are disposable and obsolete after about 5 years. Guitar is a lifetime investment in your love for the instrument and making music.
Value of an iPhone => Distract you from what's important, video an event instead of enjoying the moment, excuse for not visiting with someone in person.
What an ending!
Boy, you hit the nail on the head. It's a matter of priorities and need. If you've got a relatively new phone, unless you're going to make movies, a new one isn't necessarily needed. As you pointed out, there is the eventual obsolescence in today's technology. However, if you need a guitar, and who doesn't need another guitar, guitars do not go obsolete. A guitar is forever.
the only important thing is which can you make more $$$$ with
I have a iPhone 8 and it about time for a new phone it doesn’t hold a great charge and has almost lived it’s life! I Need a Taylor!! I have a Strat. So I’m going with a guitar💯….! I need a Taylor!!!! It is a better investment and it won’t lose charge!!
Still using an iPhone 7. Skipped the 8, 10 , 11, 12, and bought a Taylor 324CE instead!!
I agree. Guitar is much better..
But the Smartphone can do so much more for the money. The Fender dosen't even take pictures or make phonecall.
"we read all comments, even the creepy ones" 😂😂 that just killed me
Guitar make me happy 🙂
The enabler cut in was hilarious! Rock on!
The guitar, because it could last a lifetime, and an iPhone lasts a couple years and then you change it for a new one
That’s what I tried to explain to my wife when I bought a 324ce builders edition. I’ll get years of enjoyment out of it and then it will get passed on to one of the kids when I’m gone
An used guitar is the most sensible choice. Will retain 90% of the value
Guitar, not into phone technology
Chris, this is a phenomenal video idea. I love guitars. In fact, it could be said I have a problem with GAS. However, the concept that a quality instrument is a MUCH better investment than a new phone or computer that will be obsolete within 3 years is genius. Well done, sir. Even my wife agrees.
Learn to play music on the phone: Easy; push the Spotify button. And the tone will always exactly match your guitar hero.
Learn to play music on the guitar: Takes the rest of your life. But it's way, way more rewarding than just listening to a stream.
Blah blah blah…..
You convinced me to buy an OM-28 Modern Deluxe. So I have no money for an iPhone.
Thanks man. 🙂
Amazing video. I would take the guitar for sure 🎸
Well, if you don't need a new phone, then a new phone is a terrible value because most of what a new phone offers simply duplicates what your old phone did. But… the same can be said about a guitar. If you already have a phone and guitar, then buy lessons. Or, just show some discipline just like a real adult and save it.
I'll take the guitar and buy it from Sweetwater!